top of page

Online Ordering

You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.

Accepting Orders
Pickup time: Nov 26, 8:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Pickup Address: 11 High Street, Nutley, NJ 07110

Menu

Seasonal Menu Items

If you run into any issues with online ordering, please contact us. Please message if you need an alternate p/u or delivery!

Sold in sets of 3, 6 or 12, these are the perfect addition to your holiday dessert table! Set of 3: 1 design choice Set of 6: 2 design choices Set of 12: 4 design choices

$19.50

Sold in sets of 3, 6 or 12, make your family and guests say WOW with these cookies that taste even better than they look! Set of 3: 1 design choice Set of 6: 2 design choices Set of 12: 4 design choices

$19.50

Sold in sets of 3, 6 or 12, make your family and guests say WOW with these cookies that taste even better than they look! Set of 3: 1 design choice Set of 6: 2 design choices Set of 12: 4 design choices

$19.50

The perfect activity for you and the family! A set of 8 cookies -- choose up to 4 different shapes and 4 different colors to decorate your own cookies!

$40.00

Featured

The perfect gift for the ultimate sweet tooth! Great for surprise birthday deliveries, milestones and that "just because" gift. 1x 5" cake of choice (feeds 4-6) 6x Decorative sugar cookies 1x flower bouquet to match colors of box

$130.00

Featured

Sold by the dozen - Your choice of color scheme and customized inscription 4x Plaque with "Happy Birthday (name)" 4x Round with age 4x Balloon

$78.00

Sold by the dozen - The perfect item for your next engagement party, proposal celebration or wedding favor!

$60.00

Sold by the Dozen - Choose from chocolate, vanilla or red velvet cake pops with 2 colors per dozen (base color & piping color)

$54.00

Customize this with colors, patterns and age to make the perfect customized treat box! Please specify what you're looking for in "special requests" section.

$18.00

One dozen classic chocolate chip cookies with crisp edges, a soft chewy center, and pools of melted chocolate—comforting & timeless.

$35.00

Rich, fudgy double chocolate cookies made with olive oil for a soft, tender bite—deeply chocolatey and just so happen to be vegan!

$35.00

Sold by the dozen - Choose from dark, milk or white chocolate

$33.00

Sold by the dozen - the perfect addition to your celebration!

$36.00

The perfect blend of sweet and salty!

$24.00

Sold by the dozen - A great addition to your dessert table events or gift for your loved one!

$24.00

Sold by the dozen - A great snack for yourself or gift addition for your loved one!

$20.00

Sold by the dozen - Great for kids parties or a gift for that special person in your life. Your choice of cake flavor and frosting color.

$25.00

Sold by the dozen - A great addition to your dessert table events or gift for your loved one!

$17.00

631-413-1513

11 High St 1L

Nutley, NJ 07110

Stay in the know! Join our mailing list

We respect your privacy. Any personal information you provide (such as name, contact details, and order preferences) is used only to process your order, respond to inquiries, and improve our service. We never sell or share your information.

​

Allergy Disclaimer

We offer gluten-free, vegan, and allergy-friendly options, but we are NOT a nut-free or allergy-free facility. Cross-contamination is possible. Please order at your own risk.

​

Order & Cancellation Policy
  • A 50% deposit is required to confirm all orders.

  • Deposits are non-refundable if canceled by the client.

  • If we must cancel, you will receive a full refund of your deposit.

  • All sales are final. No refunds or exchanges once your order is completed.

​

Contact Us

more questions? Reach out at:
📧 info@goldenbutternj.com | 📞 631-413-1513 (call or text) | 

bottom of page